• Over Likoed
  • Steun ons
  • Contact
dinsdag, januari 19, 2021
Abonneren
Likoed Nederland
7 °c
Jerusalem
  • Home
  • Publicaties
    • Artikelen
    • Brieven
    • Persberichten
    • Acties
  • Achtergronden
  • Geselecteerd
    • Clips Palestijnse televisie
    • Video’s
    • Uit de pers
    • Historische documenten
    • Nederlandse links
  • De Nederlandse media
    • Ongehoord Palestijns nieuws
    • Dossier: media leugens
    • De Nederlandse media: niet evenwichtig
    • Kennisquiz Midden-Oosten
  • English
    • Answers to Frequently Asked Questions
    • Clips of Palestinian television
    • Video’s
    • Arab Extremism
    • From the Press
    • Historic documents
    • Israeli Government Points of View
    • Likud Policy Statements
    • English links
    • About Likud
Geen resultaat
Toon alle resultaten
Likoed Nederland
Geen resultaat
Toon alle resultaten
Likoed Nederland
Home English From the Press

Arithmetic of pain

20 juli 2006
in From the Press
Reading Time: 3min leestijd
Tweet
Share
Pin
Share
0 Shares

By Alan Dershowitz, Professor at the Harvard Law School.

July 20, 2006.

There is no democracy in the world that should tolerate missiles being fired at
its cities without taking every reasonable step to stop the attacks. The big
question raised by Israel’s military actions in Lebanon is what is “reasonable.”

The answer, according to the laws of war, is that it is reasonable to
attack military targets, so long as every effort is made to reduce civilian
casualties. If the objectives cannot be achieved without some civilian
casualties, these must be “proportional” to the civilian casualties that would be
prevented by the military action.

This is all well and good for democratic nations that deliberately locate their
military bases away from civilian population centers. Israel has its air force,
nuclear facilities and large army bases in locations as remote as anything can be
in that country. It is possible for an enemy to attack Israeli military targets
without inflicting “collateral damage” on its civilian population.

Hezbollah and Hamas, by contrast, deliberately operate military wings out of
densely populated areas. They launch antipersonnel missiles with ball-bearing
shrapnel, designed by Syria and Iran to maximize civilian casualties, and then
hide from retaliation by living among civilians.

If Israel decides not to go after them for fear of harming civilians, the terrorists
win by continuing to have free rein in attacking civilians with rockets. If Israel
does attack, and causes civilian casualties, the terrorists win a propaganda
victory: The international community pounces on Israel for its
“disproportionate” response.

This chorus of condemnation actually encourages the terrorists to
operate from civilian areas.

While Israel does everything reasonable to minimize civilian casualties – not
always with success – Hezbollah and Hamas want to maximize civilian
casualties on both sides. Islamic terrorists, a diplomat commented years ago,
“have mastered the harsh arithmetic of pain. … “Palestinian casualties play in
their favor and Israeli casualties play in their favor.”

These are groups that send children to die as suicide bombers, sometimes
without the child knowing that he is being sacrificed. Two years ago, an
11-year-old was paid to take a parcel through Israeli security. Unbeknownst to
him, it contained a bomb that was to be detonated remotely. (Fortunately the
plot was foiled.)

This misuse of civilians as shields and swords requires a reassessment of the
laws of war. The distinction between combatants and civilians – easy when
combatants were uniformed members of armies that fought on battlefields
distant from civilian centers – is more difficult in the present context.

Now, there is a continuum of “civilianality”: Near the most civilian end of
this continuum are the pure innocents – babies, hostages and others completely
uninvolved; at the more combatant end are civilians who willingly harbor
terrorists, provide material resources and serve as human shields; in the middle
are those who support the terrorists politically, or spiritually.

The laws of war and the rules of morality must adapt to these realities. An
analogy to domestic criminal law is instructive: A bank robber who takes a teller
hostage and fires at police from behind his human shield is guilty of murder if
they, in an effort to stop the robber from shooting, accidentally kill the hostage.

The same should be true of terrorists who use civilians as shields from
behind whom they fire their rockets. The terrorists must be held legally and
morally responsible for the deaths of the civilians, even if the direct physical
cause was an Israeli rocket aimed at those targeting Israeli citizens.

Israel must be allowed to finish the fight that Hamas and Hezbollah started,
even if that means civilian casualties in Gaza and Lebanon. A democracy is
entitled to prefer the lives of its own innocents over the lives of the civilians of
an aggressor, especially if the latter group contains many who are complicit in
terrorism.

Israel will – and should – take every precaution to minimize civilian
casualties on the other side. On July 16, Hasan Nasrallah, the head of
Hezbollah, announced there will be new “surprises,” and the Aska Martyrs
Brigade said that it had developed chemical and biological weapons that could
be added to its rockets. Should Israel not be allowed to pre-empt their use?

Israel left Lebanon in 2000 and Gaza in 2005. These are not “occupied”
territories. Yet they serve as launching pads for attacks on Israeli civilians.
Occupation does not cause terrorism, then, but terrorism seems to cause
occupation.

If Israel is not to reoccupy to prevent terrorism, the Lebanese
government and the Palestinian Authority must ensure that these regions cease
to be terrorist safe havens.

Tweet
Share
Pin
Share
0 Shares

Gerelateerd Artikelen

Islamic Relief Duitsland
Persberichten

VS waarschuwen tegen de antisemitische organisatie die minister Kaag (D66) wil subsidiëren

by Awi
13 januari 2021
0

Persbericht van Likoed Nederland, 13 januari 2021. Het Amerikaanse bureau voor de bestrijding van antisemitisme waarschuwt voor de organisatie ‘Islamic...

Lees meer
will return liberate Palestine

De Palestijnen willen de tweestatenoplossing niet

10 januari 2021
Illegale Palestijnse huizenbouw

Ministerie verzwijgt details van illegaal handelen voor Tweede Kamer

6 januari 2021
King Mohammed V visits synagoge

De Abraham akkoorden: doorbraak in het Midden-Oosten

15 december 2020
aid money

Het bedrog van Palestijnse leiders

10 november 2020
Fatah peace Bahrain UAE

Vredesverdragen zijn alleen omstreden bij extremisten

2 november 2020
Volgend Artikel

Excuses Hezbollah voor dood kinderen

Bestaan van Israël staat weer op het spel

Laatste artikelen

Islamic Relief Duitsland

VS waarschuwen tegen de antisemitische organisatie die minister Kaag (D66) wil subsidiëren

13 januari 2021
will return liberate Palestine

De Palestijnen willen de tweestatenoplossing niet

10 januari 2021
Illegale Palestijnse huizenbouw

Ministerie verzwijgt details van illegaal handelen voor Tweede Kamer

6 januari 2021

Recommended

Bedrog als strategie

9 jaar geleden

Teaching terror: how Hamas radicalizes Palestinian society

20 jaar geleden
Laad Meer

Popular News

  • Illegale Palestijnse huizenbouw

    Ministerie verzwijgt details van illegaal handelen voor Tweede Kamer

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • VS waarschuwen tegen de antisemitische organisatie die minister Kaag (D66) wil subsidiëren

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • De Palestijnen willen de tweestatenoplossing niet

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Eenzijdigheid bij de NOS

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Geen terroristenvereerder in het nieuwe kabinet

    338 shares
    Share 338 Tweet 0

Like ons op Facebook

Connect met Likoed Nederland

Help ons! Deel onze berichten met uw vrienden op al uw sociale netwerken. Hoe meer likes, retweets etc hoe hoger Likoed scoort in de zoekmachines, dank voor uw hulp!

Abonneren

Abonneer u op al onze nieuwe artikelen, u ontvangt steeds als eerste een email wanneer er een nieuw artikel op de website staat.

Abonneren

Category

  • Aanbevolen video's
  • Achtergronden
  • Acties
  • Arab Extremism
  • Artikelen
  • Brieven
  • Clips Palestijnse televisie
  • Dossier: media leugens
  • From the Press
  • Historic documents
  • Historische documenten
  • Israeli Government Points of View
  • Likud Policy Statements
  • Ongehoord Palestijns nieuws
  • Persberichten
  • Publicaties
  • Uit de pers
  • Video's

Likoed Internationaal

  • Likoed Israel (Ivriet)
  • Likoed Israel (Engels)
  • Likoed Israel (Russisch)
  • Likud-Herut UK
  • American Friends of Likud

Over Likoed Nederland

In Nederland is Likoed geen politieke partij maar een vereniging.

Voorlopers van Likoed Nederland maakten sinds 1930 onderdeel uit van de Nederlandse Zionistenbond. Die is in 1899 opgericht om het zionisme in Nederland te bevorderen. In 1992 is die omgevormd naar de Federatie Nederlandse Zionisten en is Likoed Nederland een zelfstandige vereniging geworden.

Lees meer over Likoed Nederland

  • Over Likoed
  • Steun ons
  • Contact

© 1997 - 2019 Overname van artikelen is toegestaan en wordt zelfs zeer op prijs gesteld, onder voorwaarde van bronvermelding en een link naar het originele artikel op likoed.nl.

Geen resultaat
Toon alle resultaten
  • Home
  • Publicaties
    • Artikelen
    • Brieven
    • Persberichten
    • Acties
  • Achtergronden
  • Geselecteerd
    • Clips Palestijnse televisie
    • Video’s
    • Uit de pers
    • Historische documenten
    • Nederlandse links
  • De Nederlandse media
    • Ongehoord Palestijns nieuws
    • Dossier: media leugens
    • De Nederlandse media: niet evenwichtig
    • Kennisquiz Midden-Oosten
  • English
    • Answers to Frequently Asked Questions
    • Clips of Palestinian television
    • Video’s
    • Arab Extremism
    • From the Press
    • Historic documents
    • Israeli Government Points of View
    • Likud Policy Statements
    • English links
    • About Likud

© 1997 - 2019 Overname van artikelen is toegestaan en wordt zelfs zeer op prijs gesteld, onder voorwaarde van bronvermelding en een link naar het originele artikel op likoed.nl.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In